Lily's Chocolate

  Flavors Tried: 

• Bars: 
• Almond Dark, Crispy Rice, Extra Dark
• Cookies & Creme (White)
• Creamy Milk
• Chocolate Chips:
• Dark Chocolate
• Peanut Butter, Unicorn
• Semi-Sweet

Yet To Try: 

• Bars:
• Birthday Cake White, Original White, Peppermint
• Blood Orange Extra Dark, Coconut Dark, Extremely Dark, Intensely Dark, Mocha Hot Cocoa, Original Dark, Salted Almond Extra Dark, Salted Caramel Extra Dark, Sea Salt Exta Dark
• Hazelnut Milk, Salted Almond Milk, Salted Caramel Milk
• Filled Bars:
• Creamy Caramel Dark Chocolate, Hazelnut Butter Dark Chocolate, Peanut Butter Filled Dark Chocolate
• Chocolate Chips:
• Butterscotch White
• Chocolate Cinnamon, Chocolate Espresso, Chocolate Mint, Chocolate Pumpkin Spice, Chocolate Salted Caramel, Hot Cocoa with Marshmallow, Milk Chocolate
• Peppermint, Pumpkin Spice, Raspberry and White Chocolate, White Chocolate
• Nuts & Others:
• Dark Chocolate Caramel Popcorn, Dark Chocolate Coated Pieces, Dark Chocolate Covered Almonds, Dark Chocolate Covered Caramels
• Milk Chocolate Caramel Popcorn, Milk Chocolate Covered Almonds, Milk Chocolate Covered Caramels, Milk Chocolate Covered Peanuts, Milk Chocolate Peanut Candy Coated Pieces
• Gummy Bears, Peach Rings, Sour Gummy Worms, Sour Watermelon

Overall Rankings

1. Cookies and Creme (77)

2. Extra Dark (76)

3. Almond Dark, Creamy Milk (Tie, 72)

4. Crispy Rice (68)

General Thoughts

This brand is very popular, but frankly I'm not sure I get it. I guess it's chocolate that keto people can have? These are stevia-sweetened, which is fine, but most of the calories in chocolate come from fat! Each bar is still like 300 calories, and frankly I don't get the hype. They have lots of exotic flavors though, which is really nice.

Price

At ~$4-5 per bar, but sometimes on clearance, 10/15.

Chocolate Bars

Fullness Factor

This isn't a massive bar, but it's somewhat filling? Compared to Gatsby though, it's nothing, since you can have two Gatsby's for one of these (and Gatsby is already a bigger bar, though roughly the same by weight!). 10/15.

Almond Dark

• Nutrition: 390 Cals, but 0g added sugar, and quite a bit of fiber (24g!). These are high in saturated fat, but theoretically the good kind 24/35.
• Taste: Very good - there are real almond chunks, and I'm definitely a dark chocolate lover! Still, I prefer salted. 28/35
• Overall: 72

Cookies & Creme

• Nutrition: Better at 320Cals, but less fiber. 25/35.
• Taste: This was delicious and very different! I liked it better than Gatsby's take on this flavor. 32/35.
• Overall: 77

Creamy Milk

• Nutrition: 370Cals, 27g fiber, 24/35.
• Taste: Honestly, pretty standard milk chocolate. Maybe a little richer than your average chocolate bar? 28/35.
• Overall: 72

Crispy Rice

• Nutrition: Same ordeal (370). 24/35.
• Taste: Very tasty and accurate, I've just never been a massive fan of crispy rice chocolate flavors. You might like this more than I did. 24/35.
• Overall: 68

Extra Dark

• Nutrition: Basically the same (360 cals), 24/35.
• Taste: Exactly what it purports to be, but very good! Has a better texture than Gatsby, and just the right level of sweetness. 32/35.
• Overall: 76

Chocolate Chips

Overall Rankings

1. Unicorn Swirl (77)

2. Dark Chocolate (76)

3. Peanut Butter (74)

Nutrition

These are all quite similar to the bars, though the Dark Chocolate ones are slightly better (10 cals less per serving, but honestly I suspect it's due to rounding). 24/35.

Dark Chocolate Chips

• Taste: Basically the bar in chip form, but no complaints here! It is however a little sweeter IMHO. Still, they nailed the texture and taste, and I honestly like how these are slightly smaller than their other chips. Also, you get a ton per serving! 32/35.
• Overall: 76

Peanut Butter

• Taste: Lovely, but the peanut butter flavor is mild. You can tell this is white chocolate based. Still very good, but I would have preferred more peanut flavor. 30/35.
• Overall: 74

Unicorn Swirl

• Taste: I didn't know what to expect, but this delivered. Maybe it's some weird mental effect, but I loved these - they were divine. Like a mix of cookies and cream and cotton candy (ok that sounds kind of disgusting, but not as fruity as cotton candy). 33/35.
• Overall: 77